lunedì, febbraio 23, 2015

"When legality becomes distinct from morality"


Ieri gli Oscar hanno premiato anche Citizenfour, il documentario su Edward Snowden e le rivelazioni del Datagate, sulla sorveglianza di massa e sull'attacco alla privacy.

Oggi Laura Poitras, Edward Snowden e Glenn Greenwald hanno risposto alle domande degli utenti di Reddit. Qui una risposta di Snowden, una riflessione che mi ha colpito particolarmente:
Ultimately, if people lose their willingness to recognize that there are times in our history when legality becomes distinct from morality, we aren't just ceding control of our rights to government, but our futures.   
How does this relate to politics? Well, I suspect that governments today are more concerned with the loss of their ability to control and regulate the behavior of their citizens than they are with their citizens' discontent.  
How do we make that work for us? We can devise means, through the application and sophistication of science, to remind governments that if they will not be responsible stewards of our rights, we the people will implement systems that provide for a means of not just enforcing our rights, but removing from governments the ability to interfere with those rights.  
You can see the beginnings of this dynamic today in the statements of government officials complaining about the adoption of encryption by major technology providers. The idea here isn't to fling ourselves into anarchy and do away with government, but to remind the government that there must always be a balance of power between the governing and the governed, and that as the progress of science increasingly empowers communities and individuals, there will be more and more areas of our lives where -- if government insists on behaving poorly and with a callous disregard for the citizen -- we can find ways to reduce or remove their powers on a new -- and permanent -- basis. 


Our rights are not granted by governments. They are inherent to our nature. But it's entirely the opposite for governments: their privileges are precisely equal to only that which we suffer them to enjoy. 
We haven't had to think about that much in the last few decades because quality of life has been increasing across almost all measures in a significant way, and that has led to a comfortable complacency. But here and there throughout history, we'll occasionally come across these periods where governments think more about what they "can" do rather than what they "should" do, and what is lawful will become increasingly distinct from what is moral.   
In such times, we'd do well to remember that at the end of the day, the law doesn't defend us; we defend the law. And when it becomes contrary to our morals, we have both the right and the responsibility to rebalance it toward just ends.

5 commenti:

Sophia Carlot ha detto...

ciao

Io sono una particolare offerta prestiti a tassi di interesse bassi per gli individui, le piccole imprese, investimenti personali ecc ...
Sono i prestiti locali ed internazionali per persone in tutto il mondo.
Selo metta in contatto oggi e fammi sapere la quantità di denaro
si vuole dare. Sono pronto a soddisfare voi in massimo 48 ore o 72 ore dal ricevimento della vostra applicazione formulata. Contattatemi per informazioni sulle mie condizioni di prestito. E-mail: sophiacarlot@gmail.com

Sophia Carlot ha detto...



Io sono una particolare offerta prestiti a tassi di interesse bassi per gli individui, le piccole imprese, investimenti personali ecc ...
Sono i prestiti locali ed internazionali per persone in tutto il mondo.
Selo metta in contatto oggi e fammi sapere la quantità di denaro
si vuole dare. Sono pronto a soddisfare voi in massimo 48 ore o 72 ore dal ricevimento della vostra applicazione formulata. Contattatemi per informazioni sulle mie condizioni di prestito. E-mail: sophiacarlot@gmail.com

Ann Ann ha detto...

Il RasenBallsport Leipzig e.V. (abbreviato RB Leipzig – in italiano RB Lipsia – e anche noto impropriamente come Red Bull Leipzig), è una società calcistica tedesca con sede nella città di Lipsia, in Sassonia.poco prezzo
magliette calcio
maglie calcio 2017, Maglia inter milan outlet

Ann Ann ha detto...

Our Browns House Flag hangs vertically and provides a top sleeve for insertion of your flagpole. The Browns House Flag measures 28x42 inches, is constructed of 2-ply polyester, and both sides are dye sublimated with the NFL team logo as shown.house divided flags nfl
house divided flags nhl
nfl house flagscheap Philadelphia Eagles banners

paola castini ha detto...

Ciao! Per tutte le vostre necessità di prestito di denaro o finanziamento solo uno su di voi del progetto aiuta la signora cinzia. Lei ha aiutato ad per avere un prestito di anticipo sicuro e gratuito.
e-mail: cinziamilani62@gmail.com